URGENT: ORDER MOM'S FAV BUNDLE BOX BY MAY 7TH FOR ARRIVAL BY MOTHER'S DAY 🥨💕

  • Mega Mystery Box
  • Mega Mystery Box
  • Mega Mystery Box
  • Mega Mystery Box
  • Mega Mystery Box

Mega Mystery Box

Regular price

❓ Mystery Selection – No two boxes are the same!

🚚 Ships FREE – No mystery here!

🥨 Over 40oz of Hand-Twisted Pretzels  – A snacking experience like no other!

🍯 Premium Dip - Your choice of "mystery" dip!

  •  ✅ Regular – Classic flavors that complement any pretzel.
  •  🌶️ Spicy – For those who love a kick of heat.
  •  🍯 Sweet – Perfect for a delightful contrast.
  •  ❓ Surprise Me – Let us pick something unexpected!
Ready to ship

We keep it simple.

  • Flour

  • Water

  • Brown Sugar

  • Salt

  • Yeast

  • Canola Oil

Why? You'll love it!


Each Mega Mystery Box offers a unique combination of pretzels and dips, making every unboxing an exciting experience.​

Our pretzels are meticulously hand-twisted and baked to perfection, ensuring a soft, chewy interior with a golden-brown crust.​

With over 40 oz of pretzels, this box is perfect for sharing at gatherings, gifting to fellow pretzel enthusiasts, or savoring over multiple occasions.

The Perfect Snack for Every Occasion

​Embark on a flavorful journey with our Mega Mystery Box, where each unboxing reveals a delightful assortment of our handcrafted Bavarian-style soft pretzels. Made in York County, PA—the Snack Food Capital of the World—our pretzels are crafted from a simple, traditional recipe using only the highest-quality ingredients: flour, water, yeast, salt, brown sugar, and non-GMO canola oil. While the ingredients may be straightforward, the experience is anything but ordinary.​

Your soft pretzels will arrive unsalted, accompanied by heating instructions to ensure optimal enjoyment. For lasting freshness, freeze any pretzels not consumed within 24 hours; they reheat beautifully straight from the freezer using your oven, toaster, or grill. Dive into the mystery and savor the surprise that awaits in every Mega Mystery Box.

What’s Inside Our Mystery Box

  • Pretzels

    Every Mega Mystery Box contains a delicious mix of our hand-twisted pretzels and fan-favorite dips, but what’s inside is up to fate!

  • Mystery Dip!

    It's all about the fun!

freshly baked pretzels

  • Add Mega Mystery Box to your basket.

    1

  • Order online with secure payment.

    2

  • Receive fresh pretzels delivered to your door.

    3

FAQ

Find the most frequently asked questions below.

Most orders ship within 5-7 days of
being placed, but this can vary depending on weather and temperature delays,
carrier notices, and production schedule.

Orders are shipped Monday through
Thursday via UPS Ground, FedEx Home Delivery, or FedEx 2nd Day Air depending onyour region.

Our soft pretzels are fresh, never frozen, and shipped to you the same day they were baked.

We recommend that you freeze your pretzels within 24 hours of their arrival if you don’t immediately devour them!
Once frozen, your soft pretzels will keep for approximately three (3) months /
90 days.

1) Heat toaster oven, conventional oven, or air-fryer to 350 degree F

2) Spray water or brush melted butter to lightly moisten your
pretzels

3) Apply desired amount of salt or cinnamon sugar to pretzels

4) Place on a cookie sheet or directly on the rack

5) Heat for 3-5 minutes or until your desired crispness

Each box contains over 40 ounces of our hand-twisted, freshly baked pretzels, offering a delightful surprise assortment that may include Signature Twisted Pretzels, Monster-Sized Pretzels, Pretzel Nuggets, Soft Pretzel Braids, and more.

This mix of flavors and textures ensures an amazing snacking experience with every bite

Customer Reviews

Based on 2667 reviews
82%
(2200)
7%
(193)
5%
(125)
2%
(63)
3%
(86)
J
John Cearlock
Great pretzels

I freeze my boxes as soon as I receive them. I keep a couple thawing in the refrigerator for eating. 4-5 minutes in the air fryer at 375 degrees and they’re ready for rubdown with stick butter and a little salt. These are as close to fresh Amish or Mennonite pretzels you’ll ever get. I highly recommend them. They keep well with a box of 8 lasting about two months for the wife and I. Great product and shipping has been impeccable so far through three orders.

D
Deborah Smith
Fresh and Tasty

The pretzels arrived fast and we're great.

C
Caryn Tatasciore
Great pretzel

My family fully enjoyed this box of pretzels!

D
Debbie McRaney

Very good

G
Gayle Cohen
Good pretzels

I bought the mystery box. I love your pretzels but not very fond of the “roll” pretzels.

Load More

Ready to Order Your Mega Mystery Box?

Shop Now
{"statementLink":"","footerHtml":"","hideMobile":false,"hideTrigger":false,"disableBgProcess":false,"language":"en","position":"left","leadColor":"#146ff8","triggerColor":"#146ff8","triggerRadius":"50%","triggerPositionX":"right","triggerPositionY":"bottom","triggerIcon":"people","triggerSize":"medium","triggerOffsetX":20,"triggerOffsetY":20,"mobile":{"triggerSize":"small","triggerPositionX":"right","triggerPositionY":"bottom","triggerOffsetX":10,"triggerOffsetY":10,"triggerRadius":"50%"}}